In the first chart here, daily bars updated through last Friday, Dec. 10, clearly the S&P 500 has robustly broken out above the cluster of resistance levels we’ve been watching these last few weeks. Thus, at least the short term outlook is for continued uptrending.
I’m now concerned about the long and very long term outlook. See the second chart here, the quarterly bars chart from 1950. Price is now up against those two primary red resistance curves, whose levels I have marked on the daily bars chart. Also notice that for the last dozen years, both the RSI and the MACD are showing strong negative divergences from price, suggesting imminent weakness on this timescale. It could be that price will continue up through these R levels and then exhibit weakness in a few quarters or years from now. Or, price could turn down from the R levels. So, we should watch price behavior as price encounters these R levels on the short term chart. Indeed, this Monday morning, price is getting ever closer to the lower R level, having hit 1244.5 so far this morning, where the lower R level is at 1250.9.


I agree.
Just a quick & dirty guestimate…
If you assume the imbalance started in 1971 with the recognition of abandonment of a low stable inflation rate, then mean reversion will mean we hit SP 350 around spring of 2012.
This fits with some basic P/E analysis I did back in 3/09 http://content.screencast.com/users/Dastardly_Dave/folders/Jing/media/9fb26845-7900-43c4-9125-f62dde26fd1c/2009-03-21_0135.png
So yes, long term (up until early 2012) we are in trouble.
After that, I expect we will return to a stable, low inflation environment, and there will be a true recovery as the necessary structural reforms will be in place.
Dave,
Thank you for your thoughtful and insightful observations. It certainly is true that the market crash of 2008 did not take us anywhere near the complete washout that has always followed the bursting of an extreme bubble. One telling metric is that previous washouts, in the 1930s and 1970s, took the 12-month trailing P/E of the S&P 500 to under 7, and so far we haven’t even gone below 15.